Charitable Remainder Annuity Trust Case Study
Estate Plan Concerns
Bill and Mary (both age 65) presently own 20,000 shares of stock in Widget Industries, Inc. This stock, bought several years ago for $100,000, has been an extraordinary investment, and it is presently trading on the New York Stock Exchange at $50 per share (making the shares worth $1,000,000).
► Diversification Will Cause Capital Gains Tax
Their investment advisor has recommended for some time that they sell the Widget stock and diversify their holdings. Bill and Mary agree that this is good advice, but they hesitate, knowing that they will lose $135,000 in capital gains taxes, as well as all the future earnings on the amount lost to taxes.
► Desire for Sizeable Donation After Death
Over the years, Bill and Mary have enjoyed contributing to various charities, and they have expressed an interest in someday making a sizable gift to their favorites. They wouldn’t be comfortable making such a gift during their lifetimes, because they want to be sure that their own financial needs are met. However, they think that a large gift to their favorite charities after their deaths would be a good idea.
Estate Plan Solution
After careful consideration, Bill and Mary decide to use a planning technique known as a Charitable Remainder Annuity Trust. The technique will allow Bill and Mary to avoid capital gains taxes upon the sale of the stock, provide them a lifetime income, generate an income tax deduction, save estate taxes, and provide a large gift to their favorite charities after their deaths.
Charitable Remainder Annuity Trust Process
Charitable Remainder Annuity Trust Process
- Bill creates an irrevocable trust, known as a Charitable Remainder Annuity Trust, or “CRAT”, from which Bill and Mary will receive a stream of income for as long as either is alive. The income stream is based on a fixed percentage of the value of the trust assets, determined annually. Trust assets remaining after the survivor’s death will be transferred to the qualifying charities they have designated.
- Bill transfers Widget stock worth $1,000,000 to the trustee.
- Bill and Mary receive a distribution from the trust, annually, equal to $70,000. The amount of this payment is determined at the time the trust is created by multiplying the value of the trust’s assets by a percentage specified by Bill in the trust agreement (7% in this scenario), and remains fixed for the duration of Bill and Mary’s beneficial interest in the trust. Note that payments could be made more frequently, e.g., quarterly or monthly.
- Bill and Mary also can benefit from an income tax deduction, which is based on the actuarial value of the charity’s remainder interest (using tables provided by the IRS).
- The trustee sells the stock in return for cash. Because the trust is tax exempt, no capital gains tax is owed upon the sale of the stock. The trustee invests and manages the proceeds to provide the annual distributions to Bill and Mary.
- Upon the death of the survivor of Bill and Mary, remaining trust assets are distributed to the designated charities and the trust ends. The value of the trust assets pass to the designated charities estate tax free.
- Steady Income: Income stream payable to the donor and spouse for as long as either is alive.
- Income Tax Benefit: Income tax deduction available for the computed value of the charitable gift.
- Tax-Exempt Trust Manages Investments: Investments are managed inside an income tax exempt trust, making investment decisions easier.
- No Capital Gains Tax: The trust can be used to sell a highly appreciated asset and avoid capital gains tax.
- Donation is Tax-Free: Trust assets pass free of estate and income taxes to designated charity after donor’s and spouse’s deaths.
- Public or Private Foundation Option: Designated charity can be donor’s favorite charity (including donor’s private foundation).
A Charitable Remainder Annuity Trust (CRAT) is a special type of irrevocable “split interest” trust in which a fixed income stream, the amount of which is determined by multiplying the value of the trust assets by a specified percentage, is payable to a non-charitable beneficiary for life or for a specified period of time not to exceed 20 years, with remaining trust assets being distributed to a qualifying charity (the remainder beneficiary) at the end of the non-charitable beneficiary’s interest. Such trusts can be created during the settler’s (i.e., the trust creator’s) lifetime or at the time of death (e.g., under the decedents will).
► Trust Benefits Self and Spouse While Alive; Charity Receives Remainder of Assets
Typically, the settler designates himself / herself as the non-chartable income beneficiary of the CRAT for the duration of his or her lifetime, with one of more favorite charities designated to receive the trust’s assets at death. The settler can also include his/her spouse income beneficiary of the CRAT so that income can be received as long as either the settler or the spouse is alive. Someone other than the spouse could be named as an additional income beneficiary, although this is usually not done due to gift and estate tax issues. The designated charity can be changed after the creation of the trust, if the settler reserves in the trust instrument the right to do so.
► Technical Requirements to Qualify for Tax Relief
To qualify for favorable income, gift and estate tax treatment, the CRAT must satisfy various technical requirements. Examples: the specified percentage used to determine the annual distribution amount from the trust must not be less than 5%, nor more than 50%; the actuarially computed value of the charity’s remainder interest must be at least 10%; the trust must satisfy the “5% Exhaustion” test” and the designated charity must be a qualifying charity under federal tax law (which could include the settler’s private foundation).
► Interest on Trust Assets Available as Itemized Deduction
The actuarially computed value of the charity’s remainder interest will be available to the settler as an itemized deduction as a charitable contribution for federal income tax purposes in the taxable year that the asset is transferred to the CRAT. Generally, the amount of the gift that is deductible will be determined by rules governing deductibility of charitable gifts, which include limitations based on the taxpayer’s adjusted gross income, the type of asset transferred and the type of charity involved. To the extent that these rules do not allow for deduction of the entire amount in the taxable year that the asset is transferred to the CRAT, the unused amount may be carried over to the following 5 taxable years.
► Trustee Income Type and Benefits Distribution Determine Income Tax
Generally, the trust is exempt from federal income tax, which provides a significant tax advantage in the sale of the assets and management of investments in the trust. Generally, the income beneficiary will be subject to income tax on trust distributions, based on the character of the income in the hands of the trustee (e.g., ordinary income, capital gains, nontaxable return of principal), and is determined by applying detailed rules governing the timing and order of distribution.
► Trust Funding and Management Decisions Important to Maintain Beneficiary Income
It is important to understand that while the trust agreement provides for payment of a fixed annuity to the income beneficiary, the annuity can be paid only so long as the trust has sufficient assets to pay it. Consequently, it is important that the invested assets of the trust be managed prudently and in a manner consistent with the need to make annuity payments to the income beneficiary. Generally, the trust should be funded with assets that can produce a substantial and consistent stream of income. However, certain types of assets are not appropriate. For example an operating business produces income that would be treated as unrelated business taxable income, resulting in a federal excise tax equal to 100% of the amount of the unrelated business taxable income received by the trust for the taxable year.
► Settler’s Heirs May Need to Replace “Disinherited” Assets in Trust
While the CRAT offers numerous benefits, a disadvantage of the CRAT is that it effectively “disinherits” the settler’s family as to the assets held in the trust. Consequently, settler’s often create for their family a so-called “asset replacement trust,” funded with life insurance, to replace the wealth lost to charity.
► Calculations Will Vary According to Current Market
Unless otherwise stated, actuarial calculations are based on the assumptions that the client is 65 years old and the Applicable Federal Rate (AFR) is 5.00%.
Tax Reduction Formulas To Protect Your Future
We provide unique tax minimization formulas, based on a customized strategic combination of IRS-approved investment programs and technical tools, which lead to maximum asset protection, to defend against the many known and unknown volatile forces that risk the prosperous future you and your heirs desire and deserve.
View our Estate Planning Periodic Table to see the many options we have available to custom-design an estate plan that exactly meets your specific goals for the future.
The following notice is required by the IRS: Any U.S. Federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended to be written or used, and cannot be used or relied upon, to avoid tax-related penalties under the Internal Revenue Code, or to promote, market or recommend to another any tax-related matter addressed herein.
Read More Stories